top of page

Subscribe to BLOG here:

Thanks for submitting!

Recently Published in the Times of Israel: Eisenkot, Fauda, and the Mizrahi Jews

53 minutes ago
8 min read

Gadi Eisenkot has just received the presidential mandate to form Israel’s next government. The son of Moroccan immigrants, Eisenkot could be the country’s first Mizrahi prime minister. Most Westerners may think, “Well, so what? Another Israeli may be the next prime minister. What’s the big deal?” Some might even add, “At least it’s not Netanyahu!”

 

When it comes down to the differences between Netanyahu and Eisenkot, there’s a lot more going on than may meet the Western eye. Just to clarify, Netanyahu descended from Eastern European Jews; Eisenkot grew up in in the Arab world of Morocco.


(For more on the significance of Ashkenazi – Mizrahi differences and their effects on Israeli politics—and thus the world—please see my post: “Ashkenazi or Mizrahim—Who Won the Israeli Election?” on my blog: An Israeli-Palestinian Primer: A Guide for Mainline Christians.)

 

My readers express great surprise when they learn about some essential differences between political factions or even among the many different ethnicities and cultural groups that make up Israel’s complex existence. One way to learn about Israel is to turn on your television and check out the popular Netflix series, Fauda, a word in Arabic: فوضى‎, fawḍā, meaning “chaos” or “disorder.”

 

The first time you watch the show, you think you’re getting a thriller. You think you may be watching an Israeli action drama about the mista’arvim—undercover Israeli soldiers trained to pass as local Arabs while hunting Palestinian terrorists.

 

Watching Fauda is not exclusive to an Israeli audience; in fact, in Lebanon, it’s ranked as the number one most-watched Netflix show. Equally high ratings are found in Jordan, the UAE, Qatar, Bahrain, Kuwait, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia, where it can be watched in Arabic as well as Hebrew.

 

Western viewers find it hard to imagine these audiences in the same room—much less watching the same Israeli-produced television show.

 

The men who created Fauda—Lior Raz (Iraqi and Algerian parents) and Avi Issacharoff (Kurdish Iraqi and Uzbek)—actually served in the undercover units the show portrays. The real men and the characters they portray are the direct descendants of Mizrahi Jews who are able to operate inside Arab societies because they are native to those societies.

 

Additionally, Fauda realistically portrays the Middle Eastern region, where Israel endures the long game against groups committed to its elimination, and it tells that story in a language both Amman and Tel Aviv can watch.

 

Like Gati Eisenkot, the Israelis who created the show are Jews whose families came from the Islamic world. Eisenkot came up in the same world that Fauda puts on screen. He spent decades in the IDF, and now, his possible rise to Prime Minister puts his history and political background at the top of Israeli politics.

 

By humanizing the key players, Fauda does more than show blood and guts. Audiences see human stories that illustrate the devastating effects of war on Palestinians as well as on Israelis. Mothers weep, fathers and sons disagree and fight, spies use guile to betray friendships, and larger military presences on both sides exact uncontrollable body counts.

 

In Season 3, for example, undercover work is not a quick operation. “Doron” (played by Lior Raz, one of the show’s creators) has been living for months in a West Bank town under the name, “Fadi.” He coaches boxers and sits at the family table of one of his students, Bashar, where he is treated warmly as a local. His undercover identity must hold long enough to build real trust inside the family circle so he can reach a Hamas operative connected to them. When that trust breaks and his cover is blown, the young boxer is left torn between the mentor he trusted and a family that wants proof he is not a mole. The betrayal shatters Bashar and leaves him suspected by his own community of being a collaborator.

 

Although Fauda is a fictional tale, the show’s popularity in Arab countries supports the idea that Fauda has some fundamental substance and more than a nod to the reality of the region. It offers a gritty view of Israel that Mainline Christians are surprised to visit on screen.

 

I share that surprise, having grown up in Euclid, Ohio in a Lutheran family—about as middle-of-the-road American as you can get!

 

Now, as a Lutheran minister—and after visiting and living in Israel—I look at my fellow Christians with great concern because of their lack of knowledge. In 2025 the ELCA passed a memorial calling on members to petition U.S. leaders to recognize and act to end “the genocide against Palestinians,” and to halt military aid to Israel used in Gaza. The vote was 742–38. The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) has voted to call the Gaza war a genocide, to divest, and to urge an arms embargo. Other mainline bodies have moved in the same direction.

 

Church committees have no words that can fit broken trust and ruined lives onto a political spreadsheet.

 

What the show can and cannot do

 

A television series is not a legal brief. Fictional representations do not erase the harsh conditions of Palestinian life under occupation. Television cannot pretend that Hamas or Hezbollah are background details. Fauda does not settle whether a specific Israeli strike in Gaza was lawful. The show does, however, accomplish something my church world almost never does. It drops you right into a conflict that does not play by the rules of a Western church committee.

 

Last month, in my Times of Israel post “How Western Dreams of Peace Crash on Israeli Soil,” I wrote about why that vocabulary dies in the Mizrahi towns that live under rocket fire. This gap in understanding may be easier to see in a language mainline churches can watch. 

 

The problems and difficulties these church resolutions address are real. Israel governs millions of Palestinians who are not citizens. Checkpoints, settlements, and the absence of a political horizon anyone believes in were not invented by a church committee in Louisville or Chicago.

If a resolution stopped at “this cannot go on forever, and Palestinian life counts,” I might argue with its condemnation, but I would share its grief.

 

These church resolutions do not stop here. They reach for the heaviest words in the Western moral vocabulary: “apartheid,” and now, “genocide.” Genocide is a legal term. It requires proof of intent. It is not a word for a horrific urban war with a staggering civilian toll. You can look at Gaza and be sickened. I am. But, once that word goes into the official minutes, the church stops talking about a war and just slaps a permanent label on Israel.

 

The same resolutions leave out facts that change the picture. Hamas’s stated aim is not a border dispute. It is the elimination of the Jewish state. October 7 was an application of that aim, not a context for it. The resolutions demand nothing comparable of Hamas or of Palestinian leadership.

 

Israel’s 2005 withdrawal from Gaza, which my church world celebrated as a breakthrough, made Gaza into a launch pad rather than a territory separated from Israel by an ordinary border. Many Israelis who had wanted the deal have now concluded that “land-for-peace” only arrived with more rockets. According to the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, more than 19,000 projectiles crossed into Israeli territory between October 7, 2023, and mid-2024. If you leave those facts out, you are lying by omission.

 

Because the church leaves those facts out, its study packets still treat Israel like a white European colony that needs to behave better. The men who wrote Fauda do not come from that European world.

 

Who made the show

 

As noted above, Raz and Issacharoff already knew the undercover life from the inside. Besides their real-world experiences, both men joined the Brothers-in-Arms volunteers on October 7, 2023. Among their many duties, they drove under rocket fire into Sderot to help evacuate families.

 

Their production of Fauda has become one of the most-watched Israeli stories on earth, precisely because it was created by men from the Islamic world with Arabic as a working language. Additionally, great care was taken during the production to polish the various languages and spoken dialects—another reason for the show’s popularity.

 

Besides attention to language detail, Raz and Issacharoff already know that local Israeli and Arab communities don’t hear abstract moral statements the way a Western church council does. The mista’arvim survive on screen because they can read a room; they recognize nuances and cultural appearances that we Westerners can’t differentiate one from the other. As an example, my church friend admitted that she can’t tell the difference between Arabic and Hebrew. She said that all the dialogue on Fauda sounds the same to her!

 

 

 

Yaakov Zada Daniel, who plays “Eli.” In his real life, Daniel served in Duvdevan, the undercover unit the series fictionalizes. When he read the audition pages he told the writers, who had served in that unit themselves, that the part was for him. They had no doubts, but cast him on the spot. The writers did not invent that soldier. They already knew his work.

 

Additionally, Nazareth-born Hisham Suliman, Shadi Mar’i, Firas Nassar, Rawad Azar, and other Arab Israeli actors play a large share of the Palestinian roles. For citizens inside the Green Line—pre-1967 borders—biases against the actors can be harsh. At the same time, however, these artistic representations can provide pathways to understanding.

 

Fauda is a work of fiction that contains many accurate portrayals of life in Israel, Gaza, and the West Bank. Its popularity across the Middle East is proof that it contains compelling elements that reach Arabs and Jews alike. Israelis watch the show in huge numbers and argue over how rough and morally gray it gets. Arab viewers watch it too, even while they criticize its Israeli point of view.

 

Of course, this television show will not dissolve the fact that Israel rules people who are not its citizens. What it can do, however, is show a Western audience that Israel inhabits a place where people live side by side in Hebrew and Arabic. The show is built in part by Jews from Arab cities like Baghdad and Algiers, and the cast and crew are composed of Jewish, Palestinian, and Arab citizens.

 

Mainline churches may condemn Israel from inside their conference rooms, and, while their statements may be based on Christian tenets, their conclusions are often based on uninformed positions. Praying for peace is a laudable Christian objective, but while peace negotiations languish, condemning Israel for defending herself may not be the best approach. Church signatures on a resolution can’t stop a missile from hitting Israeli targets.

 

In a parallel comparison, putting Eisenkot in the prime minister’s chair will not automatically change Israeli policy. Still, it breaks open the false narrative—the European colonial story that Western critics like to tell about Israel. Rather than simply European, Israel is a Middle Eastern Jewish state. And, unlike the propaganda that paints Israel as a country at odds with all Arab nations, Israel has already made real peace with several Arab neighbors.

 

Church resolutions still lack a line for that reality. Like many Western anti-Israeli perspectives, pro-Palestinian protesters claim to see the issues in black and white. They forget there are gray areas, and although it’s fiction, Fauda provides a glimpse into those many gray areas.

 

Doron sits at Bashar’s family table for months, and they treat him like one of their own. That trust is real and so is the affection right up until the moment his cover is blown. The fallout hits Bashar, whose neighbors now see him as a traitor.

 

That’s what the work of an undercover IDF agent looks like. The crises and the traumas happen up close and in more than one language. Additionally, the men who once worked undercover, along with the men who wrote the show, grew up in the same Arab world Eisenkot’s family came from.

 

Mainline Christians don’t sit at the same multi-lingual, multi-cultural table as most Middle Easterners do. Eisenkot might become prime minister, or he might not. Either way, the table is already set.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2035 by Train of Thoughts. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page